| Minutes of the: | 15th meeting of Ecma TC57 |
|---|---|
| held in: | Teleconference |
| on: | 29 September 2026 |
| Chairs: | Chris Bieneman (Microsoft), Farzon Lotfi (Microsoft) |
| Attendees: | Keith Stockdale (Microsoft), Mark Herdeg (AMD), Kaitlin Peng (Microsoft), Daniel Brown (AMD), Greg Mitrano (Microsoft), Gregory Roth (Nvidia), Deric Cheung (Microsoft), Helena Kotas (Microsoft), Justin Bogner (Microsoft), Alexander Johnston (AMD), Hai Nguyen (Nvidia), Damyan Pepper (Microsoft), Sarah Spall (Microsoft), Ashley Coleman (Microsoft), Finn Plummer (Microsoft), Jesse Barker (Invited Expert) |
| Secretary: | Aki Rose Braun (Ecma International) |
1 Welcome, opening and meeting logistics
Chris Bieneman (Microsoft), chair of TC57, began the teleconference and welcomed attendees. Attendees were reminded of the committee’s code of conduct, Ecma’s IPR policy, and TC57’s royalty-free patent policy extension. All attendees were informed that the meeting was recorded and transcribed by Zoom for the purpose of note-taking, and directed to review the video recording and legal disclaimer if they were not familiar.
2 Approval of the minutes of the virtual meetings of September 2026
There were minutes pull requests for the 01 September meeting as well as the 15 September meeting. The committee reviewed each individually, confirming they’d reviewed each PR. The chair marked them as approved and merged.
3 Review of the agenda
The meeting’s agenda pull request was proposed and approved at the start of the meeting.
- Roadmap View
- Draft Status
- Chair Elections
- Editorial Meetings
- Stage advancements
- 0013 - named casts to Accepted
- 0019 - size type to Refinement
- Normative Language
- For 2026-10-13
- Normative Language
- Stage Advancements
- 0003 - overload resolution to Completed
- 0004 - 202x removals to Completed
- 0005 - cbuffer contexts to Completed
- 0009 - hlsl namespace to Completed
- 0015 - const member functions to Completed
- 0016 - Non-member operator overloading to Completed
- 0018 - User-defined conversions to Completed
- 0013 - named casts to Accepted
- 0019 - size type to Accepted
- Updated Implementation States
- [Math.ConversionFunctions] Fix incorrect escaping - #208
- [0006] Fix missing language about inferring array bound
4 Editors’ report
There was no report from the editor meetings today.
5 Proposals
5.1 New proposals
There were no new proposals on the agenda.
5.2 Stage advancement
The following stage advancements were presented and approved; the vice chair merged the PRs.
- 0013 - named casts to Accepted
- 0019 - size type to Refinement
5.3 Future stage advancements
The following proposals and PRs will seek advancement/approval to merge at the 16th plenary on 29 September. The chair requests that all delegates review and engage in the conversation to resolve any potential concerns before then.
- Normative Language
- Math.GeneralFunctions
- Chris briefly presented this PR to alert Gregory Roth (Nvidia) to a small change from an earlier version of the text in terms of naming of a section and emphasized that given the length of this PR it is vital it is reviewed by several people
- Math.GeneralFunctions
- Stage Advancements
- 0003 - overload resolution to Completed
- 0004 - 202x removals to Completed
- 0005 - cbuffer contexts to Completed
- 0009 - hlsl namespace to Completed
- 0015 - const member functions to Completed
- 0016 - Non-member operator overloading to Completed
- 0018 - User-defined conversions to Completed
- 0013 - named casts to Accepted
- 0019 - size type to Accepted
6 Discussions
6.1 Normative consensus PRs
The following PRs contributing normative language were approved and the chair merged.
- Lex.Literal.Vector
- Inspired by the content of this PR, Gregory Roth brought up an orthogonal matter regarding re-introducing language enabling creation of 4-element vectors, which as it turned out did not have a related tracking issue. Gregory took an action item to create the issue and add it to the roadmap.
- Lex.Literal.Char
- Chris Bieneman brought to the committee’s attention that the normative addition here matches the DXC implementation and was therefore restricted to UTF-8 Unicode literals.
6.2 Updated Implementation States
Several proposals have been updated to provide up-to-date links regarding the progress on implementation of each. In merging this PR before generation of the next monthly report, the report will reflect more accurately the committee’s progress.
6.3 [Math.ConversionFunctions] Fix incorrect escaping - #208
This PR fixes a rendering issue showing double escaped underscores and includes no normative changes.
6.4 [0006] Fix missing language about inferring array bound
This is a pull request to provide further information regarding declaring an array bound. Specifically, that a declaration declaring an array with a bound allows for the omission of the bound on a subsequent definition.
6.5 UINT in proposal 0019 - size type
Jesse Barker (Invited Expert, Unity) inquired why UINT is treated differently in the list of sized types, leading to a discussion of uint not being a keyword. There is a tracking issue in Lex.Keywords. This was discussed at greater length in the 04 August meeting.
6.6 HLSL Strings (#200)
Keith Stockdale (Microsoft) followed up on any further discussion of HLSL strings. Chris Bieneman recapped the existing issue, and the committee reached consensus to treat string definition as a defect instead of putting it through the proposal process, and that the strawman solution in #200 is the preferred solution.
7 Any other business
7.1 Chair elections
The committee had previously planned for chair elections at this meeting. Chris Bieneman was the only candidate and was elected by acclamation. He proposed Justin Bogner (Microsoft) as vice chair, and there was no dissent.
Chris will remain chair, and Justin Bogner will take the place of Farzon Lotfi (Microsoft) as vice chair. The committee and the secretariat thank Farzon for his contributions.
Chris will take an action item to update any public-facing documentation.
8 Next meetings
The next meeting will be held on Tuesday, 13 October 2026 at 09:00 PDT.
Meetings are held via Zoom call every other Tuesday at 09:00 PDT (12:00 EDT, 18:00 CEST). Meeting times during seasonal time changes will be scheduled based on US Pacific (America/Los_Angeles) time.
8.1 Future Agendas
Agendas are viewable in GitHub and remain available in perpetuity.
9 Conclusion
The Chair wrapped up the meeting and the call concluded.